Government Slaps ₹1.5 tn GST Demand on Gaming Companies!

Good Afternoon ☕

The ripples of colossal tax demands are echoing throughout India’s online gaming sector, potentially unsettling its foundations. The Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) is poised to levy tax demands amounting to ₹1.5 trillion ($18 billion), creating a maelstrom of legal and financial turmoil for the industry.

Unraveling the Imminent Tax Typhoon: India’s Online Gaming Industry Grapples with Hefty Tax Demands"

Sporta Technologies, a harbinger of top-notch fantasy gaming via its platform, Dream11, has sounded the legal alarm bells, challenging the alleged retrospective tax notices by the DGGI in Bombay High Court. This initiative illustrates the broader sentiment of defiance, rippling across industry giants such as Games24x7, Head Digital Works, Junglee Games, Baazi Games, and Mobile Premier League, who are bracing for similar tax onslaughts.

A Symphony of Legal Voices

Senior lawyers versed in representing gaming maestros claim that a string of notices is being tailored by the DGGI, signaling an incoming tax tempest. Even smaller firms like WinZO find themselves on the radar. Dream11 is concurrently navigating through tax intimations for FY20 to FY22, anticipated to be laden with escalating tax claims from the DGGI. A government official further intensifies the scenario, hinting at a significant ₹55,000 crore short-payment of taxes with penalties.

Companies are battling back by approaching courts to counteract these notices. The industry, despite being cornered, is not seeking ministerial intervention, reflecting its reliance on legal precedents and a beacon of hope to mitigate such tax burdens. Dream11’s petition brings forth arguments on constitutional grounds and challenges the unreasonable restrictions imposed on its trading rights.

Comparative Perspective and Industry Implications

This scenario draws parallels with Vodafone’s iconic tax case in 2012, emphasizing the absence of provisions for retrospective claims on the new GST rate and highlighting the violation of legal precedent by the DGGI. The industry’s petitioning strategy underscores its stance against categorizing them with gambling and lottery sectors and resisting retroactive tax imposition.

Until FY23, online gaming entities have been complying with the GST at 18% of their net earnings. However, the impending demands reflect a skyrocketing rate of around 28% on gross revenue, profoundly influencing the economic equilibrium of these entities and challenging the established tax norms. The trajectory of these developments projects a vital insight into the legal and economic landscapes of the online gaming industry in India. The industry’s proactive legal countermeasures and reliance on constitutional provisions underscore its resilience and strategic approach to safeguarding its interests.

This storm is more than just a series of legal battles; it’s a reflection of the industry’s resilience and its fight to establish fair, clear, and equitable tax norms, bringing a new dimension to our understanding of entrepreneurial challenges and institutional responsiveness in India’s evolving digital economy.

For our valued subscribers, this analysis offers a multi-faceted perspective on this ongoing saga, interweaving the legal, economic, and entrepreneurial strands into a coherent narrative, enriching your comprehension of the dynamic interplay between institutional mechanisms and industry imperatives in India’s vibrant digital ecosystem. Keep abreast of this evolving story with us as we explore the intersections of law, economy, and innovation in the vibrant tapestry of India’s online gaming industry.

Important News of the Day

1. Byju’s plans to cut 4,000 staff after CEO change

India's largest edtech startup, Byju's, is planning to cut around 4,000 to 5,000 jobs in the coming weeks as part of a massive restructuring exercise under its new CEO, Arjun Mohan. The affected workforce will include senior executives, which will reduce the firm's high cost of senior management-related expenses. The restructuring exercise aims to simplify operating structures, reduce the cost base, and better cash flow management. Byju's has already eliminated more than 10,000 full-time and contract positions in the past two years.

2. India could be the largest beneficiary: JPMorgan CEO on options beyond China

JPMorgan CEO for Asia Pacific, Filippo Gori, believes that India could be the largest beneficiary as companies look for options beyond China. JPMorgan is poised to witness robust growth in India, Australia, and Japan next year. Gori expects India to be among the three fastest-growing markets for JPMorgan in 2024. JPMorgan's decision to include Indian bonds in its emerging market index will enable an estimated additional inflow of $25 billion. JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon said “the optimism on India is actually completely justified,” citing moves the country has made in recent years to boost baseline capabilities.

3. Indian trio shoots gold in women's 25m pistol event

Indian shooters Manu Bhaker, Esha Singh, and Rhythm Sangwan won the gold medal in the women's 25m pistol team event at the Asian Games on September 27, 2023. The trio fired in tandem to secure the top prize, while Manu Bhaker finished at the top of the qualification standings in the women's 25m pistol event, scoring 590. This is India's fourth gold medal at the Hangzhou Asian Games.

4. Adani Ports to buy back $195 million notes due in 2024 in cash tender offer

Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone Limited has announced a tender offer to purchase for cash up to $195 million of its notes due in 2024 at a price below their original issue. The company has started a tender offer to buy the outstanding 3.375% senior notes due in 2024 for up to $195 million in cash. The offer is expected to expire on October 25, 2023. The company has previously bought back $200 million of its notes due in 2024 in June 2023.

5. Nijjar killing row: ‘Canada has seen a lot of organized crime’, says Jaishankar

Indian External Affairs Minister, S Jaishankar, accused the Canadian government of not taking action against terrorists and extremists living in Canada, amid a row over Hardeep Singh Nijjar's killing. Jaishankar stated that Canada has seen a lot of organized crime and that the government's inaction was "politically inconvenient".

6. India-Canada feud threatens to hurt trade, investment

Tensions between India and Canada are putting their trade and investment relations at risk. The strained bilateral ties stem from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau accusing New Delhi of orchestrating the assassination of a Sikh separatist leader in British Columbia. A proposed early-stage trade deal is in jeopardy, potentially hurting India’s efforts to woo the West. Investments between Canada and India rose to C$36.2 billion in 2022, up 37% in four years, according to Statistics Canada data. The Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA) between Canada and India could boost two-way trade by as much as $6.5 billion, yielding a GDP gain of $3.8 billion to $5.9 billion for Canada by 2035.

7. ‘India-China relationship has never been easy’, says EAM Jaishankar

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said that the India-China relationship has never been easy, highlighting its cycles of conflict and cooperation over 75 years. Despite tensions, there has been no military fatality on the border since 1975. The India-China relationship has gone through cycles of conflict and cooperation over the years.

8. Govt’s GST claims from gaming firms may touch ₹1.5 tn

The Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) is expected to issue tax demands of up to ₹1.5 trillion ($18 billion) to companies in the online gaming sector for alleged underpayment of taxes over several years. Three senior lawyers representing top online gaming firms said the DGGI is preparing notices across various firms in the industry.

9. Halt imports of rough diamonds, trade association tells members

Major diamond trade bodies in India have appealed to their members to halt imports of natural round diamonds for two months from 15 October to 15 December this year. The move comes amid plummeting prices of polished diamonds and a slump in exports of polished diamonds from India. The Russian diamond producer Alrosa has already suspended rough diamond supply for September and October after a request from India's leading trade body. The two-month halt is expected to help prevent overstocking, but it is too early to say whether it will be adequate, given the shutdown of manufacturing centers in India during the Diwali festival in November.

10. ‘India to be NetApp’s largest market in Asia in next 5 years’

NetApp, a global data management and storage firm, is betting big on India and expects it to become the largest market in Asia in the next five years. The CEO, George Kurian, said that the company is bullish on India's growth potential despite macroeconomic headwinds. At present, India is among the top three markets in Asia for NetApp. Kurian also said that India is one of the fastest-growing storage markets in Asia, and the company aims to double its business in India. NetApp is witnessing high growth in India and aims to make the country its biggest revenue contributor in Asia.

World News 🌎

• China's economic growth target of 5% for 2023 at risk due to property crisis

• Iraq fire kills at least 100, 150 injured during a wedding ceremony

• Judge rules Trump and sons committed fraud by inflating asset values

• ChatGPT-owner OpenAI skyrockets in valuation amid AI gold rush

• North Korea accuses US, South Korea for dangerous situation in Korean peninsula

• Evergrande Chairman Hui under police control as China's property crisis deepens

• Amazon faces antitrust lawsuit from FTC, 17 US states

• Poland exploring extradition of Nazi war veteran lauded in Canadian Parliament

• If Kim Jong uses nuclear weapons, 'his regime will end': South Korean President

• ‘We support India,’ says Sri Lankan envoy on Canada's allegations

If you found this newsletter informative and thought-provoking, why not share it with someone you think would appreciate it? Forward this email to them and help spread the knowledge.

Thank you for being a part of our community, and we look forward to bringing you more exciting content tomorrow.